karen_w_newton (karen_w_newton) wrote,

Can you own a concept?

The answer is yes, but for a limited time. Patents expire a lot sooner than copyrights. But a recent case filed by the Discovery Communications against Amazon and Sony points to an interesting situation. Discovery (a.k.a. The Discovery Channel) took out a patent (17 years ago) on a device they never built. Their founder had a lot of ideas for a lot of things, and one of them was an ebook reader. He's alleging both the Sony Reader and the Kindle infringe on that patent, and he's asking to recover costs and attorney fees and triple damages, plus ongoing royalty payments for sales of Kindles and Sony Readers.

I can see if their patent is truly infringed on that he could demand royalties, but it seems to me the whole idea of "treble damages" is based on having a product. If I create something, say a gadget that you install in your kitchen, and it warns you when food is burning, and then you create something similar and market it, too, if your gadget uses my patented ideas, I can say your sales have hurt my sales by X amount and demand three times X. For some reason, lawyers call this principle “treble damages” instead of triple. The idea is to have a really punitive system for patent infringement.

But, if I never actually make a single Burning Food Sniffer, and you do, how has your product hurt my nonexistent sales? I don't see it myself. It's like encouraging people to sit down and think of everything they might ever want to manufacture, patent it, and sit back and wait for someone with the money, time, and persistence to actual build the invention so that you can soak them for all their worth. That seems true in this instance as Discovery isn't asking to stop Amazon and Sony from selling eReaders, just to pay them big bucks for the privilege.

And of course, it remains to be seen whether their patent was, in fact, infringed upon, as there are many ways to remove the outer covering from a feline. And this particular feline was skinned 17 years ago, it's difficult to imagine the technology in the new eReaders existed when that happened. But we'll see.

Update: It seems Barnes & Noble may be considering marketing a wireless eReader to compete with Kindle. It's only a rumor at this point, but I wonder if Discovery will slap their names onto the same lawsuit if they do.

free hit counter

Tags: e-bookx, ebooks, ereaders

  • Balticon 50!

    So, it's been a while. But Balticon celebrated it's 50th anniversary, so I wanted to post some photos. First, here's grandmaster Larry…

  • Balticon 2013

    With my husband still recovering from surgery, we did a very abbreviated Balticon this year, only one day. In fact, I went to exactly one panel,…

  • Con weekend redux

    This year the Nebulas were a local event (see last week's post) and so I ended up with "cons" on back-to-back weekends. I went to…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic