karen_w_newton (karen_w_newton) wrote,
karen_w_newton
karen_w_newton

  • Mood:

Chick lit forever!

I stumbled across this blog by writer Jane Green in which she lauds Erica Jong for her defense of chick lit. She cites Jong's PW article which was reprinted on The Huffington Post. The thrust of Jong's article was about how women writers tend to get less recognition than men writers, especially women writers from western countries with no exotic draw of oppression or armed struggles in their background.

Two sentences from the article struck a chord: "War matters; love does not. Women are destined to be undervalued as long as we write about love."

I think this is very true. The question is, why? I can see two reasons. One is that women tend to be all encompassing in their tastes. They like love stories and adventure stories. Men tend to be much more one-sided and show little interest in reading stories that are mostly about relationships. You'll notice I said "tend." There are certainly exceptions. But basically, writers who write about relationships tend to find their audiences mostly among women, while writers who write about things like international events and dealing with mortality have both male and female readers and thus have a leg up in the potential size of their market.

The second reason, I think, is the age-old prejudice that says if only women do it, it can't be valuable. If that sounds like feminist whining, just consider the salaries for professionals in female-dominated fields like teaching, nursing, and libraries. Sure they've gotten better lately, but those fields have also become less exclusively female. Jane Green reports she is often asked if she's embarrassed to write chick lit! Do you think anyone asks Tom Clancy if he's embarrassed to write spy thrillers? Maybe we should be encouraging men to write chick lit?

As someone who writes in a genre that deals with the future (science fiction) and with the unreal (fantasy) I consider that the struggle of forming a romantic relationship still offers the most potential for reader empathy. It's one thing we can all identify with, any time any place. Gay or straight, male or female, old or young, who doesn't want someone with whom they can share their life?
Tags: chick lit
Subscribe

  • Balticon 50!

    So, it's been a while. But Balticon celebrated it's 50th anniversary, so I wanted to post some photos. First, here's grandmaster Larry…

  • Balticon 2013

    With my husband still recovering from surgery, we did a very abbreviated Balticon this year, only one day. In fact, I went to exactly one panel,…

  • Con weekend redux

    This year the Nebulas were a local event (see last week's post) and so I ended up with "cons" on back-to-back weekends. I went to…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic
  • 0 comments