karen_w_newton (karen_w_newton) wrote,
karen_w_newton
karen_w_newton

  • Mood:

On being taken seriously

My Helpful Friend sent me a link to a New York Times article about an author whose first book was published as (gasp) YA. Apparently, the "stigma" is hard to bear because no one takes you seriously if you write YA.

Well, as someone who writes spec fic, both YA and adult, all I can say is "get real." If people want to sneer at other people, they're going to find a reason to sneer. It seems to me that the only form of literature that gets real respect is "serious literary fiction" and to that I say: PHFFT! (or however you spell a raspberry)

A more interesting aspect of the article was that the line between YA and adult is blurring. Well, yeah, if you think "YA" means simplistic, dumbed-down stories, then yes, the line is blurring. People are writing good, entertaining, useful books in which the protagonist is young. Actually, they've been doing that for years. That is, in fact, where today's adult readers came from. They all used to read YA.

Addendum
The woman who wrote this NYT essay seems to have hit a nerve. Lot of blog entries link to it!




free hit counter

Tags: genre
Subscribe

  • The Primeval Conundrum

    If you have been to a convention lately in which Connie Willis was a speaker, you will have heard about Primeval. The show is a British science…

  • My Nebula weekend

    I made it to the Nebulas! I have never been to a “Nebula Weekend” before. For a long time I thought you had to be in SFWA to go (you…

  • Take a spin on The Cloud Roads (my idea of a review)

    The Cloud Roads, by Martha Wells 300 pages Night Shade Books (2011) This is not the usual sort of review that summarizes (aka, gives away) the…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic
  • 4 comments